WWHS Centerstage Production of Arsenic & Old Lace

Murder and mayhem make for hilarious chaos in the dark comedy, Arsenic and Old Lace, which delighted audiences at Whitman’s Performing Arts Center on November 13th and 14th. The high school’s theatre company, Centerstage Productions, stages a drama every fall, and director Dr. Susan Radin Turner felt this old classic would challenge her actors.
“I thought the idea of the old lady serial killers was clever, and it offered opportunities for good characters for the actors. Anytime there are good characters, I'm interested. I like comedy as well, especially physical comedy,” said Dr. Radin.
Although it’s probably best known from the 1944 movie starring Cary Grant, Arsenic and Old Lace was first produced on Broadway in 1941 and ran for three years. It tells the story of theater critic Mortimer Brewster, whose plans to marry his girlfriend are derailed when he discovers a corpse in the window seat of his beloved elderly aunts' Brooklyn home. He soon learns that the “sweet old ladies” have been fatally poisoning lonely old men with elderberry wine as an act of misplaced mercy and burying them in the basement. Add in the rest of his eccentric family - including a brother who thinks he’s President Teddy Roosevelt and another brother who is a mobster on the run from the police - and you have plenty of opportunities for the kind of fast-paced physical comedy Dr. Radin was looking for with mistaken identities and characters using all parts of the set for frantic entrances and quick exits.
Written and set in the 1940s, the show functions as a period piece, especially for high school students who don’t understand a lot of the dated references like Teddy Roosevelt’s constant use of the word “bully” and who legendary horror film actor Boris Karloff was. “We definitely looked a lot of stuff up. There were words and terminology that they didn't understand,” explained Dr. Radin. “But I think that's all part of the learning experience. If we always did things that are current or contemporary, we wouldn't be stretching ourselves as artists, and I wouldn't be expanding them as actors or building their knowledge of theater.”
Actor Landon Forlenza, who played Mortimer Brewster, said he relied on the internet to familiarize himself with the time period, and he enjoyed learning a completely different style of performance. “It's taught me a lot more about physical comedy. Usually, when I'm speaking to people on stage, it's more straight drama. With this one, it definitely is more slapsticky, and I had to learn that type of comedy,” said Landon.
For actors Alexis Forlenza (Landon’s sister) and Emily Butterfield, who played the murderous sisters Abby and Martha Brewster, the challenge came in playing a much older character with a Brooklyn accent.
“My friend Lily actually does a great impression of her grandmother who's from Brooklyn, so I think I definitely took a lot from that, and also just from my own grandmother. But keeping the Brooklyn accent consistent for the whole show was a challenge,” said Emily.
For Alexis, who usually plays much younger characters, stepping into the role of Martha meant focusing on her body language as well as her voice. “I had to work on the physicality of it, just maintaining the old lady walk and talk, and obviously getting over the self-consciousness of it.”
Thanks to the faculty members who made special cameo appearances during the weekend performances. Mr. Jose Castillo, Mr. Tom DeMartinis, and Mr. Tyler Williamson all took a turn playing the role of a potential boarder who barely escapes drinking the poisoned elderberry wine.
With this show wrapped up, we have to wait to see what’s on the boards next for our Centerstage Productions company. The musical is planned for April, but no word yet on what that show will be.
Bravo to the cast and crew of Arsenic and Old Lace!
